kumoh national institute of technology
Networked Systems Lab.

Review Comment

NSL > Works@NSL> About Review> Review Comment
Sanjay Bhardwaj, Muhammad Rusyadi Ramli and Dong-Seong Kim, "Synergic Evaluation for URLLC in Industrial Wireless Network", The 24th Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking, Poster Session, 29 Oct - 02 Nov 2018, New Delhi, India.
By :
Date : 2018-08-16
Views : 38

MobiCom2018 Posters Paper #28 Reviews and Comments= Rejected


===========================================================================
Paper #28 Synergic Evaluation for URLLC in Industrial Wireless Network


Review #28A
===========================================================================

Overall merit
-------------
3. Weak accept

Reviewer expertise
------------------
2. Some familiarity

Paper summary
-------------
The paper proposes a Synergic Evaluation for URLLC in Industrial Wireless Network.

Comments for author
-------------------
The greatest issue with this work is the scalability challenge.



Review #28B
===========================================================================

Overall merit
-------------
2. Weak reject

Reviewer expertise
------------------
2. Some familiarity

Paper summary
-------------
Authors proposed using "synergy" to achieve dynamic path selection to ensure URLLC.

Comments for author
-------------------
The concept appears promising but no implementation details are provided.



Review #28C
===========================================================================

Overall merit
-------------
3. Weak accept

Reviewer expertise
------------------
3. Knowledgeable

Paper summary
-------------
In this paper, authors have proposed a synergic control system to ensure that the source is connected to the destination through the best available path in terms of delay as well as synergy.

Comments for author
-------------------
The motivation of work for an industrial wireless network is not appropriately mentioned. It is simply the matter of a static or moving relay node, which can be feasible in diverse scenarios in wireless networks. Also, Rayleigh fading model is adopted which may not be true in many industrial applications. Further, how this synergy control system will be implemented? Some more parameters (like outage probability, diversity, throughput, complexity, etc.) need to be explored for realizing the importance of scheme. The diversity is used but not explained anywhere in the paper.