kumoh national institute of technology
Networked Systems Lab.

Review Comment

NSL > Works@NSL> About Review> Review Comment
Muhammad Rusyadi Ramli, Dong-Seong Kim, Jae Min Lee, "Hybrid MAC Protocol for UAV-Assisted Wireless Sensor Networks", Sensors Journal, 2019 (IF: 2,475) (
By :
Date : 2019-02-11
Views : 5

I am not really happy with the manuscript at all, some reasons being:- Language is rather bumpy, paper needs revision by native speaker- The proposed protocol is really just a minor variation of plenty of existingprotocols, only in a slightly new context. The novelty needs to be shownmore clearly.- Simulation methodology unclear, including the statistical significance of results,or how the other considered protocols work (e.g. whether 802.11 ran with theRTS/CTS mechanism or not, and how the protocol from Reference [21] isoperating and what its configuration is).