kumoh national institute of technology
Networked Systems Lab.

Review Comment

NSL > Works@NSL> About Review> Review Comment
Ade Pitra Hermawan, Dong-Seong Kim, and Jae-Min Lee, "Predictive Maintenance of Aircraft Engine using Deep Learning Technique", ICTC 2020, Ramada Plaza Jeju island, October 21-23, 2020 (Accepted)
By : Ade Pitra
Date : 2020-09-14
Views : 43

Dear Mr. Ade Hermawan

Congratulations! - your paper #1570668908 ("Predictive Maintenance of Aircraft Engine using Deep Learning Technique") for ICTC 2020 has been accepted.

The deadline for the Camera-Ready Paper Submission is ** September 20, 2020 **. We will post the Advance Program as soon as all the camera-ready papers are ready and conference registration is completed. Please understand our very tight schedule.

The Author Registration deadline is also September 23, 2020. For more information about the registration, please visit our web site at http://ictc.org/ and click on the Registration'.

The reviews are at the end of this e-mail or can be found at https://edas.info/showPaper.php?m=1570668908. Please revise your paper according to the reviewers' comments.


[** IEEE Publication **]

To be published in the ICTC 2020 Conference Proceedings and IEEE Xplore, at least one author (including students) of the accepted paper MUST register by paying the Regular registration fee before the camera-ready paper is submitted, and MUST present the paper at the conference (** Registration deadline: September 23, 2020 **). For more information, please visit our web site at http://ictc.org/ and click on the Registration'. Please note that the registered participants can enjoy all conference sessions (paper sessions, plenary sessions including keynote speeches, industrial sessions, special sessions, and workshops) and get conference proceedings (contained in USB memory) and coffee breaks, luncheon tickets, and a ticket for banquet.


[** Camera-Ready Paper Submission **]

All camera-ready manuscript submissions MUST be formatted with the standard IEEE conference templates and MUST be validated by IEEE PDF eXpress. The camera-ready submissions should be formatted with single-spaced, double-column pages using at least 10 pt (or higher) size fonts on A4 or letter pages in IEEE style format. For more information, please visit our web site at http://ictc.org/ and click on the Call for Papers -- Paper Submission'. The maximum paper length is 6 pages, and papers exceeding 6 pages will not be accepted by EDAS. The final camera-ready manuscript of your paper should account for all the critical reviewers feedback. Proofread your document thoroughly as there will be no possibility for further revision. You may download the camera-ready paper format at: https://www.ieee.org/conferences/publishing/templates.html

The IEEE Copyright form MUST be submitted from EDAS as well at this time.

Once you have completed the preparation of your final manuscript, IEEE PDF eXpress validation, copyright submission, and registration, you can upload your final manuscript in EDAS. All camera-ready papers must be submitted electronically, in PDF format and uploaded on EDAS. Please upload the camera-ready paper on EDAS by going to "My Papers" tab where the corresponding paper is located. In the EDAS page of your paper, click on the "Upload" icon under the column Final Manuscript and follow the instructions to upload the PDF file with the final manuscript of your paper that has been previously obtained from PDF eXpress.


[** IEEE Copyright Form Submission **]

Along with the final camera ready paper, the authors also need to submit a signed IEEE copyright form. Please submit the copyright form at EDAS by going to "My Papers" tab and clicking on the '(c)' copyright icon under the column "Copyright Form" where the paper is located. You will then be directed to an EDAS webpage in which you should click on the button IEEE Copyright Submission. You will be then redirected to IEEE eCF website where you will be able to easily complete and submit your copyright form online. Please do so no later than September 20, 2020 as this step is compulsory for paper inclusion in the technical program and its submission for publication by IEEE Xplore.


[** VISA LETTER **]

If you need any assistance for getting the visa to enter Korea, please contact ictc@kics.or.kr.

Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions.

Best regards,

Jae-Hyun Kim, ICTC 2020 TPC Chair


--------------- Reviews ------------------------------------

======= Review 1 =======

> *** Relevance: How well does the content fit the conference scope? Is this paper handling an important theme in this area?
Good (4)

> *** Completeness: Does this paper describe the problem clearly? Are the results of this paper reproducible via experiments (implementations, proofs)? How well is the result analysis done with the previous works? How clear is the paper's conclusion for the problem tackled?
Good (4)

> *** Originality: Does this paper include any novel approaches or new applications that have never been tried?
Good (4)

> *** Presentation: Are the title, abstract, and keywords appropriate? How proper is the organization and description method of this paper?
Good (4)

> *** Comments to authors: Please provide detailed comments to the authors.

The paper presents a deep learning algorithm to estimate
remaining useful life of aircraft engine. The topic is interesting, but the system model and features used as the input of the CNN and LSTM should be explained in more detail.

> *** Recommendation: Please provide your overall recommendation on the acceptance of the paper. (Final acceptance decisions will also consider literal responses to the questions below.)
Accept (4)

======= Review 2 =======

> *** Relevance: How well does the content fit the conference scope? Is this paper handling an important theme in this area?
Good (4)

> *** Completeness: Does this paper describe the problem clearly? Are the results of this paper reproducible via experiments (implementations, proofs)? How well is the result analysis done with the previous works? How clear is the paper's conclusion for the problem tackled?
Good (4)

> *** Originality: Does this paper include any novel approaches or new applications that have never been tried?
Excellent (5)

> *** Presentation: Are the title, abstract, and keywords appropriate? How proper is the organization and description method of this paper?
Excellent (5)

> *** Comments to authors: Please provide detailed comments to the authors.

The paper proposes a novel method to predict remaining lifetime of aircraft engines using deep learning techniques by combining CNN and LSTM. The simulation results show that the proposed method achieves high accuracy compared to conventional methods. This paper is well-written and the authors have shown significant result to merit publication in ICTC 2020.

> *** Recommendation: Please provide your overall recommendation on the acceptance of the paper. (Final acceptance decisions will also consider literal responses to the questions below.)
Accept (4)

======= Review 3 =======

> *** Relevance: How well does the content fit the conference scope? Is this paper handling an important theme in this area?
Good (4)

> *** Completeness: Does this paper describe the problem clearly? Are the results of this paper reproducible via experiments (implementations, proofs)? How well is the result analysis done with the previous works? How clear is the paper's conclusion for the problem tackled?
Average (3)

> *** Originality: Does this paper include any novel approaches or new applications that have never been tried?
Average (3)

> *** Presentation: Are the title, abstract, and keywords appropriate? How proper is the organization and description method of this paper?
Average (3)

> *** Comments to authors: Please provide detailed comments to the authors.

An interesting issue has been investigated. However, more extensive evaluations are required.

> *** Recommendation: Please provide your overall recommendation on the acceptance of the paper. (Final acceptance decisions will also consider literal responses to the questions below.)
Accept (4)