kumoh national institute of technology
Networked Systems Lab.

Review

NSL > Education> Review
Iyoga-[CCNC 2017] Your paper #1570314077 ('Energy Aware of Data Center for Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)')
By :
Date : 2016-10-26
Views : 48

===========================================================================
======= Review 1 =======

> *** Overall Rating: What is your overall recommendation for the paper?
Reject (50-75%) (1)

> *** Relevance: How relevant is the topic of this paper to CCNC?
Neutral (2)

> *** Novelty: How novel is the approach/topic presented in the paper?
Minor tweak of prior schemes (1)

> *** Technical Strength: Is the paper technically sound and correct
Significant flaws that may call key result of the paper into question (1)

> *** Presentation: What is the quality of presentation of the paper?
The paper can benefit from significant revision (2)

> *** Reviewer Confidence: How comfortable are you in the review decision?
Comfortable reviewing the paper (close to my area) (2)

> *** Short Summary: Please give a short summary of the paper

The work investigates the use of the Internet of things in industry related to energy savings in the data center. A topology with three levels is used.

To be the reliable network uses two networks that support up to one of them.

> *** Main Strengths (Reasons to Accept): What are the main arguments to accept the paper?

There are no large elements to support the acceptance of the work.

A positive note is the adoption of a redundant network.

> *** Main Weaknesses (Reasons to reject): What are the main arguments to reject the paper?

The work represents only a draft idea but are defined very few details about its operation.

Performance is evaluated through a simulator putting themselves in ideal cases not suitable to justify the use of architecture to real cases.

> *** Detailed Comments: Please input additional detailed comments below.

The work is in its infancy and requires further efforts to be understood and accepted.

The results obtained are not very significant since this is to evaluate the energy savings in ideal conditions and not by referring to real cases.

======= Review 2 =======

> *** Overall Rating: What is your overall recommendation for the paper?
Reject (50-75%) (1)

> *** Relevance: How relevant is the topic of this paper to CCNC?
Slightly not relevant (1)

> *** Novelty: How novel is the approach/topic presented in the paper?
Minor tweak of prior schemes (1)

> *** Technical Strength: Is the paper technically sound and correct
Minor flaws but conclusions are still believable (2)

> *** Presentation: What is the quality of presentation of the paper?
The paper can benefit from significant revision (2)

> *** Reviewer Confidence: How comfortable are you in the review decision?
Comfortable reviewing the paper (close to my area) (2)

> *** Short Summary: Please give a short summary of the paper

This paper investigates energy awareness for computing resources of the data center for industrial internet of things (IIoT). It uses simulation to provide some results. However it is much more a very short paper than a regular one.

> *** Main Strengths (Reasons to Accept): What are the main arguments to accept the paper?

The approach is interesting. However it is at a very early stage of development. Authors need to work hard on it.

> *** Main Weaknesses (Reasons to reject): What are the main arguments to reject the paper?

The approach is interesting. However it is at a very early stage of development. Authors need to work hard on it.

> *** Detailed Comments: Please input additional detailed comments below.

This paper investigates energy awareness for computing resources of the data center for industrial internet of things (IIoT). It uses simulation to provide some results. However it is much more a very short paper than a regular one. The approach is interesting. However it is at a very early stage of development. Authors need to work hard on it. Finally it is not very suitable to the Globe-IoT workshop.