kumoh national institute of technology
Networked Systems Lab.

Review Comment

NSL > Works@NSL> About Review> Review Comment
Ikechi Saviour Igboanusi, and Dong-Seong Kim, Performance Analysis of VLC-UWB Hybrid (VUH) Network for Device Connectivity. IEEE International Conference on Consumer Electronics - January 11-13, 2019. Theme: Smart Electronics: Paradigms for Secure and Green Solutions Las Vegas, USA.
By :
Date : 2018-10-05
Views : 36

Review 1 (Reviewer A)
This paper is not ready for a scholarly publications. Figures are not legible. Results are not available to make a decision.

Accept Score :Normal Reject (2)
Paper Type :Recommend as Poster Presentation (2)
Best Paper :No (0)
Main Rejection Reason :Poor or unbalanced presentation (4)
Secondary Rejection Reason :Insufficient technical details (5)
Presentation :Poor (0)
Contribution :Minor (2)
Novelty :Not novel at all (0)
Relevance :Somewhat relevant (2)




Review 2 (Reviewer C)
Related work need to be mentioned for comparison.

Accept Score :Normal Accept (7)
Paper Type :Either (0)
Best Paper :No (0)
Main Rejection Reason :No Reason (0)
Secondary Rejection Reason :No secondary reason (0
Presentation :Clear (4)
Contribution :Average (3)
Novelty :Not bad (3)
Relevance :Relevant (3)